|
Posted By
|
Message
|
AndyUK
Mascot Maniac
Registered
01/08/2002
Points
14586
   
|
19th June, 2010 at 04:03:58 -
Do we get to choose what games we think are terrible? Actually come to think of it people could easily lie in order to do a remake of something they like.
.
|
Strife
Administrator
Der Dairy Crick
Registered
21/11/2002
Points
2305
  
|
19th June, 2010 at 10:20:48 -
Actually, now that I think about it, I'd imagine that some issues might arise about whether or not a chosen game is "bad." So I think that as long as the sequel you create for it is better than the original in every way, then it's okay, even if the original game was actually good. 
What we could probably do is judge games based on "gap" between how bad the original was and how good the remake is. So a Mega Man X fangame that actually turns out a little better than the original would receive a lower score than someone who remade E.T. for the NES into something that's actually playable and really fun.
So for bad games, your mission is to make them good. For good games, your mission is to make them AWESOME. 
 Edited by an Administrator
|
Otter
Rating
Registered
29/06/2008
Points
514
 
|
19th June, 2010 at 17:44:44 -
If this is going to happen, would someone please do The Adventures of Micro Man? 
Dude... Whoa.... I totally remember that game... I had it on my old computer, it sucked! And I had some Spork the Dork or something that came with it, and a PacMan rip off called MacMan...
I'm game for this compo  I think perhaps we should just grade it on how good the click game is period, and then have extra points for the comparrison stuff.
n/a
|
Resident-Pyromaniac
More than a talking head
Registered
04/02/2010
Points
1440
|
27th July, 2010 at 03:43:42 -
alright... here's my two bits.
I think that sounds/music should be totally free-form.
and graphics/coding need to be completely original.
however,at least around 80% of characters, power-ups, enemies, etc.
should be from the original game.(their concepts, not their sprites)
what do you think? I think that's good.
Saving the world, one crisped critter at a time.
|
-MacAdaM-
Megaman Fosho
Registered
12/02/2008
Points
560
|
27th July, 2010 at 04:29:59 -
I think this competition sounds awesome, either way, I really want to do an exitebike remake. 
Your just jealous that you're not as awesome as me.
(And my megaman avatar )
|
OMC
What a goofball
Registered
21/05/2007
Points
3516
     
|
27th July, 2010 at 13:49:03 -
Originally Posted by -MacAdaM-I think this competition sounds awesome, either way, I really want to do an exitebike remake.
Go ahead! I'd love to see it!
|
The Chris Street
Administrator
Unspeakably Lazy Admin
Registered
14/05/2002
Points
48488
     
 
|
27th July, 2010 at 14:49:29 -
You're a month too late, I think this thread died back then.
n/a
|
Callebo
Possibly Insane 
Registered
10/08/2008
Points
3988
  
|
27th July, 2010 at 21:39:46 -
NOooOOoo! Bring it back to life! It's a great idea for a competition 
...Atleast thats what Batman told me!
|
AndyUK
Mascot Maniac
Registered
01/08/2002
Points
14586
|
29th July, 2010 at 16:50:20 -
It's a shame seeing such good competition ideas fade away. Although to be honest creating a complete sequel in a short space of time might be just too much to ask.
.
|
Matthew Wiese
The Fencer
Registered
01/02/2009
Points
149
|
29th July, 2010 at 20:22:42 -
It's not that the idea and competition died, it's just that I thought of the idea during a time in the summer when I had little time to do something about it. I would love if someone started this competition, I would do so, but I would really like to enter, not be a judge.
n/a
|
AndyUK
Mascot Maniac
Registered
01/08/2002
Points
14586
|
29th July, 2010 at 22:09:06 -
Haha I had the same feelings towards a competition idea I had a while back. But then again, why does it have to be a competition? If it's inspires people to make something and they enjoy doing it can't that be enough?
.
|
-MacAdaM-
Megaman Fosho
Registered
12/02/2008
Points
560
|
29th July, 2010 at 23:59:28 -
Originally Posted by AndyUK
Haha I had the same feelings towards a competition idea I had a while back. But then again, why does it have to be a competition? If it's inspires people to make something and they enjoy doing it can't that be enough?
because 'fan games' are VERY frowned upon in this community.
Edited by -MacAdaM-
Your just jealous that you're not as awesome as me.
(And my megaman avatar )
|
OMC
What a goofball
Registered
21/05/2007
Points
3516
|
30th July, 2010 at 00:11:16 -
Bad fan games are frowned upon. As are any bad games, really. 
I'd love to see more good fangames! If they faithfully recreate the experience and maybe add something extra.
|
Matthew Wiese
The Fencer
Registered
01/02/2009
Points
149
|
30th July, 2010 at 01:40:26 -
I agree with AndyUK, you should make games to make yourself happy. Sometimes I haven't made a game because this community frowns upon using ripped sprites and or making fangames.
n/a
|
Resident-Pyromaniac
More than a talking head
Registered
04/02/2010
Points
1440
|
17th August, 2010 at 01:40:52 -
hey, why use Ripped sprites when you could ask around and find some desperate sprite artist to make custom stuff for ya?
as for fangames, i'd say they're only frowned upon because (like you all said) all the fangames on TDC are totall failures.
I'm all for GOOD fangames though.
@MaCAdaM I think your MegaMan Avatar is cool...
Edited by Resident-Pyromaniac
Saving the world, one crisped critter at a time.
|
|
|
|
Advertisement
Post Reply